-
In Blog 5 I convinced you that whales might be the coolest animals on this earth. Truly mythical and remarkable creatures. Even more impressive is their ability to remove in natural ways – indirectly and directly – carbon dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere. They can thus assist us to rebalance our carbon cycle.
The presence of whales stimulates the growth of phytoplankton. This is the indirect way how whales remove CO2 from the air. Phytoplankton is namely an extremely crucial organism in the carbon cycle. The current volumes of phytoplankton capture 40% of the worldwide CO2. We can compare this to the important capture capacity of the Amazon rainforest: this jungle captures 10% of the worldwide CO2.
The feces of whales contain important nutrients such as iron (Fe) and nitrogen (N2) upon which phytoplankton is dependent. This is why there is more phytoplankton growth there where there are whales. While whales migrate over long distances – this is referred to as ‘whale conveyor belt’ - they assure the distribution of these nutrients in nutrient poor regions. Phytoplankton then grows in places where it was previously not present.
Our deep diving toothed whale friends, admired in blog 5, bring additionally in a different way nutrients to the water surface. Their dives assure mixing of the under and upper water layer. Minerals are brought up and important nutrients are inhibited from sinking to the bottom. Also this ‘whale pump’ promotes the growth of phytoplankton.
While specialists are still calculating the quantitative contribution, they agree qualitatively: more whales lead to more phytoplankton and thus more CO2 capture.
The direct way in which whales remove CO2 from the atmosphere is via Carbon Capture and Sequestration (CCS). Articles and debate on this hot topic handle most often high technological solutions that capture CO2 there where it is industrially produced. This way it is prevented from being blown into the air. The captured CO2 can then (sometimes after transport) get injected in the earth. Alternatively the captured CO2 is used for another application. This is called Carbon Capture and Utilization (CCU).
The development of CC(U)S techniques is on the rise. This comes with technological challenges and high costs. However, CC(U)S is not new. Quite the contrary, it is as old as the existence of life on earth. Every organism accumulates throughout their lifespan carbon that it has captured either directly or indirectly from the atmosphere. The same goes for whales: phytoplankton (plant) captures CO2 from the air and transforms it via photosynthesis in carbon compounds. Baleen whales eat plankton and toothed whales eat smaller water animals that have been fed by plankton. Whales are big and thus store big amounts of carbon. And they do it efficiently: a group of small animals that together consumes the same amount of plankton that would otherwise be consumed by one whale (same amount of CO2 captured from the air), have collectively a lower biomass and store thus less carbon in their bodies than that one whale.
When whales die they sink to the bottom of the ocean. This is called a ‘whale fall’. At that moment they take with them the carbon they stored throughout there life and burry it for many years at the bottom of the sea (sequestration) and so it is prevented to return back to the atmosphere. Their carcasses are, as a bonus, a source of food for deep sea life and thus promote biodiversity.
The quantification of also this carbon sink is being iterated, but the quantitative trend is the same as for the indirect pathway: more whales mean that more carbon is stored in biomass which is removed from the carbon cycle for a very long time when the organism dies.
The 1.3 million whales with who we share this world thus help us with the removal of CO2 from the atmosphere. Before the mass whaling activities in the 19th and 20th century, the whale population was up to 4 times bigger in size. Now that since 1986 industrial whaling is forbidden in most countries, there is the opportunity for recovery to pre-whaling numbers. Next to many other advantages of protecting whales and stimulating their population growth, these ocean inhabitants can thus also assist in rebalancing the carbon cycle. Impressive, isn’t it?
SOURCES:
BUTFIELD Colin & HUGHES Jonnie (authors), Z.K.H. Prins William (foreword); 2021; Eartshot – How to save our planet; Publisher John Murray; London
CHAMI Ralph, COSIMANO Thomas, FULLENKAMP Connel, OZTOSUN Sena; Nature’s Solution to climate change – A strategy to protect whales can limit greenhouse gases and global warming; December 2019
PEARSON Heidi C., SAVOCA Matthew S. COSTA Daniel P., ROMAN Joa et al.; Whales in the carbon cycle: can recovery remove carbon dioxide?; TrendsinEcology&Evolution,March2023,Vol.38,No.3 p. 238-249; March 2023
NOAA Fisheries; Whales and Carbon Sequestration: Can Whales Store Carbon?; URL: https://www.nationalgrid.com/stories/energy-explained/what-is-ccs-how-does-it-work#:~:text=CCS%20involves%20the%20capture%20of,deep%20underground%20in%20geological%20formations.; accessed at July 13th 2024
N.N.; Phytoplankton: URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phytoplankton; accessed at July 13th 2024
N.N.; Carbon cycle; URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_cycle; accessed at July 13th 2024
N.N.; Commercial Whaling Banned; URL: https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/victories/commercial-whaling-banned/#:~:text=In%201982%2C%20the%20International%20Whaling,Peru%20all%20protested%20this%20development.; accessed at July 13th 2024
MOSEMAN Andrew; How much carbon dioxide does the Earth naturally absorb?; URL: https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-carbon-dioxide-does-earth-naturally-absorb; January 26th 2024
-
Blog 5 would handle another eartshot. I wrote blog 3 and 4 about water, now it was time to start exploring the air. However, because water is so intriguing – probably secretly my favorite – I write two bonus articles about a sea animal that crosses our oceans. After the corals of blog 3 and 4, now the whales (cetacea), possibly the most amazing animals on this planet earth. Allow me to try to convince you.
This first paragraph should in fact suffice. The blue whale, one of the approximately 90 whale species, is the biggest animal to have ever existed on this earth. They are 2700 times bigger than us, 40 times bigger than an elephant and 30 times bigger than the largest dinosaur, the T-rex. Immense. If this specie would have been, 66 million years ago, suddenly erased from the face of the earth due to a comet strike, there would have been countless blockbusters dedicated to its mythical existence.
Cetacea are defined as big placental sea mammals with a hairless streamlined body, a horizontal tailfin and a blowhole at the top of their head to be able to breathe at the water’s surface. This last feature leads to gorgeous images.
This family is categorized into two subgroups: the baleen whales (mysticeti) and the toothed whales (odontoceti).The mammals of the first subgroup, the baleen whales to which the blue whale belongs, are larger than the mammals from the second subgroup. They have baleens growing down from their upper jaw which they use to filter from the water large volumes of small food (plankton). They have 2 blow holes and are extremely loud: with a for the animal kingdom record noise level of 180 dB they sing in low frequency (30 – 8000 Hz). Their songs (there are many recordings that can be found online, worth a listen) are both for communication and orientation purposes and their sound can, when voiced at the right depth, travel up to 16 000 km (10 000 miles). Professor Christopher Clark of the Cornell University explains that the whales would use their sounds for ‘echomapping’: by sending their signals and waiting for its return they map the oceans and its shores. With a hydrophone installed in Virginia (East coast of the USA) his research team can hear the song of a whale swimming near the coast of Ireland. The distance between those two places is 5500 km (3400 miles). That is incredible.
Already convinced? If not, then I continue. The mammals of the second subgroup, the toothed whales, have teeth and hunt for fish and other mid-sized sea life. Dolphins are a part of this family (all dolphins are whales) and the orca or killer whale is the biggest dolphin. Also the less known porpoises are toothed whales. The toothed whales have only one blow hole, but are similarly loud as the baleen whales, although they are noisy at higher frequency. Some species can generate and receive sounds up to 160 000 Hz. As a reference, for those of my generation who can still remember the “secret” ringtone we could hear as a 15-year-old while the teacher couldn’t: this one has a frequency of 17 000 Hz. The toothed whales use their sounds for communication as well as for ‘echolocation’: a sent signal bounces off of for example prey to which they consequently can determine the distance. The system is extremely ingenious and has thus been subject to research for multiple decades. Dolphins are even being trained by defense departments to amongst other things assist with identification of underwater mines. They perform this task with utmost precision.
In case further argumentation would be in order. Whales are true world travelers. There are species that travel from the equator to the furthers northern or southern parts of the world and back in the same year. This family of mammals thus adds to their record list, apart from being the biggest and the loudest, also performing the longest mammal migration in the world.
And oh yes, there is something else. Like all mammals whales have lungs. What is difficult to then comprehend is that they are also divers, deep sea divers. There comes record number four: the deepest dive of a mammal recorded by us was performed by a Cuvier’s beaked whale and was 2992 m deep. Other mammals do not even come close to this record number. On average whales are diving for about an hour, but the up till now longest registered dive lasted 222 minutes (more than 3.5 hours). To be able to withstand the water pressure on the lungs deep underwater, whales would purposefully collapse their lungs. Collapsed longs come with a couple of advantages for mammals that our spending time under water, but it also results in a lung capacity of literally 0 l and thus no potential oxygen transfer to the blood at the alveoli (there where the lungs transfer O2 and CO2 with blood). Whales can however, compared to humans, store more oxygen outside of the lungs: they have 2x more hemoglobin, the protein that transports oxygen in the blood, and 10x more myoglobin, the protein that stores oxygen in the muscles. Additionally, they would temporarily stop the blood flow to different organs such as kidneys and the liver. This conserves energy and thus reduces oxygen consumption. Their heartbeat slows down as well and they fold their fins to be able to slide even more aqua dynamically through the water.
All thus pretty cool. And on top of that they could be of assistance to help us rebalance our shared climate. That is story for blog 6.
SOURCES:
DARRAH P.; The fascinating differences between whales and dolphins; URL: https://www.gvi.ie/blog/smb-the-fascinating-differences-between-whales-and-dolphins/; accessed on March 3rd 2024
N.N.; Are dolphins whales?; URL: https://www.ifaw.org/journal/are-dolphins-whales#:~:text=Spoiler%20alert%2C%20dolphins%20are%20in,baleen%20whales%20and%20toothed%20whales.; accessed on March 3rd 2024
N.N.; Whale and dolphin species guid; URL: https://us.whales.org/whales-dolphins/species-guide/#:~:text=There%20are%20around%2090%20species,creatures%20in%20our%20species%20guide.; accessed on March 3rd 2024
N.N.; Difference between whales and dolphins; URL: https://seaworld.com/orlando/blog/difference-between-whales-and-dolphins/; accessed on March 3rd 2024
N.N.; Whale vs dolphin: what’s the difference between these mysterious denizens of the ocean?; URL: https://www.discoverwildlife.com/animal-facts/marine-animals/whale-vs-dolphin-whats-the-difference; accessed on March 3rd 2024
N.N.; How deep can a whale dive?; URL: https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/quick-questions/how-deep-can-a-whale-dive.html#:~:text=The%20deepest%20recorded%20dive%20was,1%2C000%20to%202%2C000%20metres%20deep.; accessed on March 3rd 2024
CHAPMAN A.; If the ocean pressure can break human bones, why don’t whales and other species die?; URL: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/culture-online/case-studies/2022/sep/if-ocean-pressure-can-break-human-bones-why-dont-whales-and-other-species-die#:~:text=Whales%20are%20adapted%20in%20amazing,these%20are%20some%20record%2Dbreakers!; accessed on March 3rd 2024
PONGANIS P. J. & KOOYMAN G. L.; How do deep-diving sea creatures withstand huge pressure changes?; URL: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-do-deep-diving-sea-cr/ ; accessed on March 3rd 2024
N.N.; Blauwe vinvis; URL: https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blauwe_vinvis; accessed on March 3rd 2024
The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica; Whale; https://www.britannica.com/animal/whale ; accessed on March 3rd 2024
MBARI R.; Whale communication; https://www.shapeoflife.org/blog/whale-communication ; accessed on March 3rd 2024
CORMIER Z.; The loudest voice in the animal kingdom; URL: https://www.bbcearth.com/news/the-loudest-voice-in-the-animal-kingdom ; accessed on March 3rd 2024
PAVID K. ; Secrets of the deepest-diving whales; URL: https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/secrets-of-deep-diving-whales.html; accessed on March 10th 2024
NELSON B.; 14 of the greatest animal migrations – Some creatures travel impressive distances in search of new habitats.; URL: https://www.treehugger.com/greatest-animal-migrations-4869293#:~:text=The%20tiny%20Arctic%20tern%20makes,for%20making%20a%20similar%20journey.; accessed on March 29th 2024
-
In Blog 3 we learned about coral reefs and their importance. And about how biodiversity flourishes near them. These ecosystems are threatened, but also already, at some places, preserved. This leads to incredible stories.
The text book example of ocean conservation is the story of Cabo Pulmo, a coastal village with a coastal area on the east coast of the Baja California peninsula in Mexico. There the underwater world is protected since 1995, was appointed national park in 2000, added to the UNESCO world heritage list in 2005 and is since 2008 a Ramsar Wetland of International Importance.
If these famous lists existed from earlier on then this unique coral reef in the Pacific Ocean was most probably already added to them since its beginning of existence, 20 000 years ago. The French writer and adventurer Jacques Cousteau called the Gulf of Cortez that includes Cabo Pulmo, ‘the aquarium of the world’. In the 19th and 20th century things however went a bit wrong. The abundance of sea live attracted an abundance of economic activity: what started with pearl harvesting, moved into shark hunt when the pearls were depleted and finally led to fishing when all sharks had disappeared. This last activity did however not remain a privilege for the local community, but also drew big trawlers to the area. Both local and commercial fishermen emptied the aquarium and damaged the reefs significantly.
This did not go unnoticed. In the 1980’s scientists of the Autonomous University of Baja California Sur started coming to Cabo Pulmo. They investigated to possibility of reef recovery and started communicating their findings and ideas with the local community. This resonated: the inhabitants of the coastal area had witnessed firsthand the impoverishment of their ecosystem and the realization that if nothing changed this could lead to a total and irreversible stop of their most important economic activity, was growing. Key figures in the community, like the members of the Castro family, started spreading the word. This local involvement assured community approval of the decision to finally proclaim the underwater world of Cabo Pulmo a protected marine area on the 6th of June 1995. This included a fishing ban that was instated in an area of more than 70 km².
This was a gamble. Was this area still viable? The first years nothing seemed to change. There was no recovery. Without a doubt, this was highly discouraging. However, the mission was not aborted and for that the world has been in the meantime, thanks to this remarkable community, rewarded: 20 years after the start of the conservation, the biomass (mass of all living species) in the protected area had increased with more than 460%. The fish stocks have completely recovered and now flow into fishing regions outside of the protected area. The village has built, besides the fishing activity that locals could restart under certain conditions, a thriving eco-tourism. And the most symbolic result of all for the inhabitants of Cabo Pulmo is that the sharks have returned to their home in the coastal area.
This is a success story. And it is proof, that protection of important (sea)areas can lead to recovery of damage brought to the region by human interaction. For the courageous villagers of Cabo Pulmo 5 to 10 years of anxiously waiting if this plan would even work out or not, must have felt like an eternity. But how incredible is it that 200 years of damage can be erased within a decennium. Nature has an inherent power for recovery.
I can easily imagine that the inhabitants of Cabo Pulmo are extremely proud today that there sea has now finally been added to those prestigious lists, to which it belongs for already 20 000 years.
SOURCES:
To who cannot get enough of this inspiring story I recommend to watch this short interview with Judith Castro – amazing!
N.N.; Cabo Pulmo World Heritage Biosphere Reserve; URL: https://ocean.si.edu/conservation/solutions-success-stories/cabo-pulmo-world-heritage-biosphere-reserve; accessed at February 10th 2024
BUTFIELD Colin & HUGHES Jonnie (authors), Z.K.H. Prins William (foreword); 2021; Eartshot – How to save our planet; Publisher John Murray; London
ERCILIA; Cabo Pulmo : a conservation success story; URL: https://blog.cabovillas.com/cabo-pulmo-a-conservation-success-story/; accessed at February 10th 2024
N.N.; A reef reborn 3D; URL: http://areefreborn3d.com/about-the-film/; accessed at February 10th 2024
N.N.; Cabo Pulmo: an ocean treasure rescued by a close-knit community; URL: https://www.cabo-adventures.com/en/blog/cabo-pulmo-national-park-history; accessed at February 10th 2024
N.N.; Cabo Pulmo National park; URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cabo_Pulmo_National_Park; accessed at February 10th 2024
-
Two years ago I lived for a work assignment on the Luzon island in the Philippines. I learned how to dive there, which was on the top of my bucket list. Diving in the Philippines means having the absolute privilege to visit the coral reefs of the region. And I can tell you, the most beautiful gardens on earth are below the water surface. The colors, the textures, the abundance, the ordered disorder, the life it houses, it is truly magnificent.
I did some research. Corals are animals. They have a diameter of 1-10 mm and they have a stomach and a mouth and tentacles which they use to catch little animals to eat. This is the first food source of the organism. One animal is called a polyp and many polyps together form a coral colony. Every polyp in a colony has the same genetic material, they are formed by asexual reproduction. Sexual reproduction takes place when the polyps exert their gametes once a year after which the fertilization takes place at the water surface. The formed ‘planulae’ sink, after floating along the current for a while, and search sturdy underwater surface to nestle. The planula metamorphoses into a polyp and the growth of a new coral colony can start.
Corals living in relatively shallow waters start a collaboration (symbiosis) with zooxhantellae, a type of algae. These algae are plants and perform photosynthesis: using the energy of the sunlight they transform carbon dioxide (CO2) and water (H2O) in sugars (organic material) and oxygen (O2). These sugars are made available for the coral. This is the second food source of the organism.
The presence of these algae is what gives the corals their vibrant colors. When corals are being exposed to a stressful environment for a significant amount of time, they expel their algae. Consequently their own, translucent color is visible. This is coral bleaching. It is important to point out that bleached corals are not dead. However, due to the absence of the zooxanthellae they lack an important food source which makes them weaker: their growth slows down and their immunity is lower. When the stress factor is removed, the zooxanthellae return to the coral an the colony can regain strength and even fully recover.
There are soft and hard corals. Soft corals have their polyps exposed, waving freely in the water. Hard corals form an exoskeleton to protect their polyps. This skeleton grows chemically: calcium ions present in the sea water react with carbonate ions to form calcium carbonate (Ca2+ + CO32- -> CaCO3). The formed CaCO3 has an aragonite crystal structure. There is no yet scientific consensus about the exact mechanism taking place that forms this skeleton, but a lot of interesting research is already published and ongoing.
Corals are being threatened and that worries us. But why exactly? Why are they important?
Even though coral reefs cover only 0.1% of the ocean surface, 25% of the ocean life is directly dependent on it for food, housing, hiding, reproduction,… This is the first reason for conservation: the coral reefs form a unique ecosystem with enormous biodiversity. Secondly, the reefs protect the land that lies behind it. They absorb the energy of waves, storms and even tsunamis and protect in this manner the coast line against erosion and destruction. Thirdly, there is a big economic dependence on the coral reefs. It is estimated that the corals generate € 9.9 billion/year. And fourthly, there is a lot of hope that scientists are able to one day use the toxins present in the corals to produce important medicines.
There are thus more than enough important reasons, on top of the conservation of natural beauty, to protect the coral reefs and their ecosystem.
SOURCES:
BUTFIELD Colin & HUGHES Jonnie (authors), Z.K.H. Prins William (foreword); 2021; Eartshot – How to save our planet; Publisher John Murray; London
N.N.; Koraalrif; URL: https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koraalrif; accessed at January 15th 2024
N.N.; Coral; URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coral; accessed at January 15th 2024
National Ocean service ; Corals tutorial ; URL : https://oceanservice.noaa.gov/education/tutorial_corals/welcome.html; accessed at January 15th 2024
Coral guardian; Why are corals so important?; URL: https://www.coralguardian.org/en/coral-reef-important/; accessed at January 15th 2024
Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary; Coral bleaching; URL: https://flowergarden.noaa.gov/education/bleaching.html; accessed at January 15th 2024
Flower Garden Banks National Marine Sanctuary; Spawning oberservations; URL: https://flowergarden.noaa.gov/education/spawningobservations.html; accessed at January 15th 2024
MASS T.; GIUFFRE A. J. ; e.a. ; July 28th 2017 ; Amorphous calcium carbonate particles form coral skeletons ; Edited by Andrew H. Knoll, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA
LIPPSETT Lonny; November 12th 2018; How do corals build their skeletons? Subtle architecture affects reefs’ ability to withstand threats; URL: https://www.whoi.edu/oceanus/feature/how-do-corals-build-their-skeletons/; accessed at January 15th 2024
-
In the early 60’s, J.F. Kennedy challenged engineers and scientists to organize a safe round trip to the moon. The deadline was the end of the decennium. The passenger had to be an American. This was, very fitting, a ‘moonshot’, a goal so seemingly unreachable that it could be perceived as being impossible. When the first successful moonwalk took place on July 21st 1969 and the three astronauts returned to earth safe and sound on July 24th 1969 the term ‘moonshot’ started being associated also with a highly ambitious goal. A goal for which, however big the challenges, there is hope for success.
This concept inspired in the beginning of 2020 to call for an EARTHSHOT, a ‘moonshot’ for this decennium. A calling to again, this time worldwide, join forces with as goal now to repair our planet. The initiator is HRH Prince William. Together with a team of partners and experts he defined the following 5 ‘Earthshots’. We are aiming for:
1. Protecting and restoring nature
2. Reviving of our oceans
3. Cleaning of our air
4. Fixing of our climate
5. Building a waste-free worldWhat a wonderful idea! By clarifying the assignment and putting a deadline (2030) they want to motivate scientists, activists, company leaders, individuals, community leaders, farmers, entrepreneurs,… basically all of us, to be innovative and to accelerate execution of planet saving initiatives.
To further enhance the motivation for these Eartshots, the ‘Royal Foundation’ decided to attach an award: The Earthshot prize. Every year from 2021 up until 2030 15 finalists are selected and eventually per category 1 winner is appointed. These are individuals or organizations that have significantly contributed to reaching one of the 5 goals. The winners are granted a monetary prize of 1 million British pond and receive support to execute their projects on a big scale. This last part seems logical and feels to me more as a prize for the world then a prize for the winner. Good initiatives should be implemented.
This thus also means that yearly 15 environment improving stories are being broadcasted. Stories that are inspiring and hopeful. Stories that will make us happy. Stay tuned!
SOURCES:
BUTFIELD Colin & HUGHES Jonnie (authors), Z.K.H. Prins William (foreword); 2021; Eartshot – How to save our planet; Publisher John Murray; London
N.N.; Conservation – The Eartshot prize; URL: https://royalfoundation.com/programme/the-earthshot-prize/; accessed at January 7th 2024
N.N.; Earthshot prize; URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Earthshot_Prize; accessed at January 7th 2024
N.N.; We choose to go to the moon; URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/We_choose_to_go_to_the_Moon; accessed at January 7th 2024
-
A very good day to all who have found their way to this site.
I am Marjon, an adventurous and curious 28-year old with a big heart for this world and a mission to embrace the climate challenges of today. Climate convention and reports, political visions, social media, new insights and further scientific investigation has made it however extremely challenging to keep a grasp on the situation. This complexity may possibly lead to frustration and despondency, which inhibits action.
With this platform we will collectively explore this story and try to simplify it without losing the nuance. To then, with big enthusiasm, take action.
I believe strongly in the individual contribution. If everyone of us takes a step in another direction, this will cumulatively lead to significant improvement. I also strongly believe in gentleness and moderation. It is up to everyone individually to identify which actions suit their lives. Each small and big effort has impact.
I have an engineering degree and have been working a couple of years now in the metallurgical industry. In addition to my scientific background I have strong emotional connection with different subjects and want to be in tune with my intuition. This duality, of ratio and emotion, will color this platform.
I pledge that for the writing of the articles on this site no AI tools will be used. Every source I consult, will be correctly mentioned.
So let us begin. With tremendous optimism I welcome you all. Let’s explore together.
Sign up to get notified by e-mail about new blog posts or events.